WorkAboutLinkedIn ↗
← All specimens

Pl. IV · Docusign · Self-service renewal

Creating a self-service subscription renewal experience in the Docusign app

How I created a new experience for scale to enable users and reduce support reliance.

Role
Lead product designer
Team
PM (sponsor), support product designer, content designer, program manager, engineering, analytics
Outcome
$137.5k+ estimated MRR, fiscal year 2025
Docusign “Manage your subscription” renewal modal, shown on a laptop and a phone
  1. 01Problem & goals
  2. 02Discovery
  3. 03Ideation
  4. 04Usability testing
  5. 05Final designs
  6. 06Results & learnings

01 — Problem & goals

Turning a manual customer support process into a seamless self-service experience

Docusign’s flagship product — eSignature — has been transitioning once-manual processes into self-service. This gradual shift has led to increased profits and an improved user experience. Application admins could purchase licenses to add team members, but before this product update, they had to contact support in order to reduce the number of licenses on their account.

Problem

The current eSignature admin experience doesn’t provide a self-service option for account administrators to decrease the number of licenses on their plan.

Hypothesis

By launching a renewal experience that allows flexibility to reduce licenses, we can reduce the strain on support center resources that currently manage this manual process.

Design goals

In addition to the project sponsor goals, I had my own design goals to improve the overall user experience:

  • Create a one-stop shop for all plan information and changes, including self-service license reductions
  • Allow cancelation of a pending plan change
  • Design email and in-product renewal notifications reflecting changes
  • Create more user-friendly language in the license removal process

Key performance indicators

  • Reduce support contacts for license removals
  • Track traffic to the new renewal experience; create a baseline for future measurement
  • Track reasons for license churn

My role

I was lead product designer overseeing the project from discovery, to concepts, to usability testing, to final design delivery. The team included a product manager (sponsor), a support product designer, a content designer, a program manager, front-end and back-end engineering teams, and analytics managers.

02 — Discovery

Current experience audit

The ability to un-assign a user from a license existed within the self-service options. That experience was reviewed to identify opportunities for improvement and note what was missing.

Current “Users” settings seat-change walkthrough

The current experience manages seat changes within the “Users” setting — not where the other account changes take place.

Opportunities identified while auditing

  1. I.
    Meet user expectations

    If this admin is accustomed to making plan changes in a specific place, the new experience should be housed there.

  2. II.
    Words matter — a lot

    Helping the admin find the renewal experience relies heavily on the words we use to identify it. Our extended team put a lot of effort into determining which words would best help the admin find this new space.

  3. III.
    Lose the system terminology

    Get rid of internal system terminology wherever possible. It’s not natural to “close” a user. If you don’t say it in real life, it shouldn’t be part of a digital transaction.

Competitive analysis

Why use a car insurance plan as inspiration?

Without a paid subscription, I hit a paywall when trying to walk through the true paid-plan renewal experience of similar SaaS products. A team member’s car insurance renewal flow helped me envision the type of experience I aimed to design.

Policy summary with charges, named insured and Edit policy button
Make policy changes: add or remove vehicles, add or remove drivers, edit coverages
Coverages overview with policy, driver and vehicle accordions
Bodily injury liability coverage options with running premium
Coverages list with Manage vehicles, Manage drivers and Continue buttons
Review of policy changes and premium changes with Update policy button
Car insurance renewal flow
Slide 1 of 6

03 — Ideation

Mapping every scenario

Many user flows were created to solve the problem at hand, while also accounting for features launching shortly after this rollout. This version isn’t the final user journey — it’s shown to demonstrate the complex scenarios I had to account for. All flows are available to view in FigJam.

User flow for changing a plan during the renewal period, from eSign settings through to checkout and provisioning the plan update
Upgrade flow exploration
Hub and spoke renewal flow model exploration with content requirements, use cases, pros and cons
Flow model expanded: hub and spoke exploration
An unwelcome surprise

The functionality I wanted wasn’t possible 💣

The issue was revealed through this exploration.

This design goal was my main priority for an optimal user experience:

Create a one-stop shop for all plan information and changes, including self-service license reductions.

After sharing extensive user flow ideations with Product Management and Engineering, it became clear it wouldn’t be possible in phase one. The compromise was to create the easiest way for a user to cancel a pending change, then introduce the desired functionality in phase two.

Early concept wireframes

Explored full-page and modal renewal hubs

Once we determined the need for a dedicated space for the renewal experience, I explored full-page vs. modal design options. I pushed for a full-page experience because it would scale better for future functionality.

The project timeline was limited by the large engineering scope, so I had to compromise on a modal experience.

Manage your renewal plan modal showing account, plan, seats and the auto renewal payment
Change your plan modal, step one of three, comparing Personal, Standard and Business Pro
Manage seats and envelopes modal, step two of three, with an order summary
Modal renewal hub: plan options, seats and envelopes, and confirmation
Slide 1 of 3
Full-page Manage Renewal Subscription showing Business Pro, annual billing and the renewal payment
Full-page Manage Renewal Subscription with the plan changed to Standard and a Changed badge
Full-page renewal hub: current plan and a pending plan change
Slide 1 of 2

04 — Usability testing

Usability testing prototype

Research findings & opportunities

User research confirmed two necessary updates:

Improve “manage subscription” findability. While I pushed to update the “change plan” button to include the manage subscription experience at launch, the research proved that update was needed as soon as possible. Ultimately, it shipped as a fast follow in the phase immediately after launch.

Revise the awkward “undo pending change” experience. While this was a compromise, it needed to be more elegant. I moved the interruptive yellow banner and button to replace the disabled button, bringing the intended action where the user expected it. Thankfully, this band-aid was removed once the back end was updated in phase two — and users could make changes as I originally intended.

05 — Final designs

Final designs were delivered to engineering with accessibility annotations, responsive screen sizes and variants for edge cases.

Reducing seats

Plan and Billing page where the flow begins, with Manage Your Subscription highlighted
Manage your subscription modal with Switch Plan and Edit Quantity
Edit seats and envelopes modal showing 2 seats
Edit seats and envelopes modal comparing 2 seats with 1 seat starting Dec. 18, 2023
What led to this change survey with reasons to choose from
Survey with Other selected and an optional comments field
Confirm your subscription comparing current and updated renewal cost
Your change is confirmed
Plan and Billing with a pending change banner and a Subscription change submitted notice
Seats and Users page prompting the admin to remove users before renewal
Gmail inbox showing the email “Your subscription has been updated”, where the flow ends
Final designs: reducing seats from Plan and Billing to the confirmation email
Slide 1 of 11

Undoing a pending change

Manage your subscription modal showing a pending change from Business Pro to Standard, with an Undo Pending Change button
Manage your subscription modal confirming the pending change was undone
Edit seats and envelopes modal comparing 3 seats with 1 seat
Confirm your subscription comparing 3 seats with 1 seat
Your change is confirmed for 3 seats to 1 seat
Final designs: undoing a pending change and making a new one
Slide 1 of 5

06 — Results & learnings

Results

12
Design iterations
$50k+
Estimated monthly recurring revenue for fiscal year 2024
$137.5k+
Estimated monthly recurring revenue for fiscal year 2025

What I learned

The design goals I had for this project weren’t realistic once I discovered back-end system constraints would limit functionality.

I had to trade off the goal of letting the user make multiple changes at once for allowing just one change per renewal period. This was a disappointment, but it further emphasized the need to fix the issue — which was addressed in the next phase. To solve for this lack of system flexibility, I created clear messaging and UI treatment so the admin understands the actions they’re able to take, and how to undo them.

Next time, I’ll ask more questions of the project sponsor at kickoff — in particular, whether the full range of stakeholders and teams are aware of the scope. If the back-end engineering team had been included earlier, I could have designed the flow knowing how system limitations impacted the user experience.

Read more specimens

  • Pl. V · DocusignContent & UI refresh on Docusign’s contact sales form →
  • Pl. I · Intuit MailchimpDesigning an Intuit Mailchimp enterprise messaging plan experiment →
  • Pl. II · SnowflakeUX writing & design for a pricing calculator on Snowflake.com →
© 2026 Linsey FoxLinkedIn ↗Back to top ↑